Hey Jessewpool,
I'm not sure why after cloning the site over from the original, the icons wouldn't be working. When I make it home tonight from work, I'll take a closer look at the new cloned site and why it may not be working.
I did a little re-write of the stylesheet for your theme, to allow for icons to work seamlessly with it. Maybe that got jumbled in the transfer? Either way, I'll have a look and will hopefully have a resolution for you.
It looks like the icons are working on the original site in ALL browsers, but its just the cloned site that is causing issue.
Did you manually clone the site yourself? Or did you use a plugin to help you out?
I'm just trying to narrow down why it may be causing issues for you.
Thanks,
Evan